The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear an appeal from a
female death row inmate who said fetal alcohol syndrome should have
been considered by the state court that reviewed her sentence.
The U.S. Supreme Court has closely monitored Louisiana's capital punishment system in recent years.
The justices gave no reason for rejecting the appeal, which challenged
the constitutionality of Louisiana's capital sentencing procedures and
argued that Brandy Holmes' alleged developmental disabilities should
disqualify her from execution.
Holmes, 29, is one of two women scheduled to be executed in Louisiana.
She and a male co-defendant were convicted of murder in the New Year's
Day 2003 death of Julian Brandon, a retired minister near Shreveport.
Holmes is being held at the Louisiana Correctional Institute for Women
at St. Gabriel.
Experts on fetal alcohol syndrome call it the
nation's leading preventable cause of mental retardation. As many as
40,000 newborns in the United States are affected each year by their
mother's alcohol use, according to an advocacy group. The syndrome can
lead to brain damage, behavioral problems and intellectual disabilities.
Holmes' attorneys said she functions like a 10- to 12-year-old.
"Brandy has a hallmark case of FAS," said Tom Donaldson, president of
the National Organization on Fetal Alcohol Syndrome, which supported
the defendant in her high court appeal.
"Her mother testified
that she drank throughout her pregnancy, and in fact named her daughter
after her favorite drink. Brandy's capacity to appreciate the
criminality of her actions or to conform to the law is very seriously
impaired."
Donaldson and others argue the medical and legal system is unprepared
to recognize, intervene and educate when presented with the majority of
FAS-related cases, especially those involving younger defendants.
In a petition to the justices, Holmes' attorney, Charles Ogletree,
argued the Louisiana Supreme Court did not "review the extensive
mitigating circumstances that limited Ms. Holmes's moral culpability
and compare them to the mitigating circumstances presented in similar
cases. The [state] court also failed to consider that petitioner's
co-defendant received a death sentence and that the prosecutor stated
at the co-defendant's trial that he (and not the petitioner) was the
more culpable party."
That co-defendant, Robert Coleman, remains on death row at the Louisiana State Penitentiary at Angola.
Ogletree is a noted Harvard Law School professor who taught President Obama when he was a law student.
The state in its reply brief noted the violent nature of the
robbery-murder. The victim's wife also suffered gunshot wounds in the
attack. She lived in a severely impaired state for years and passed
away in October 2008.
Investigators said Holmes tried to use the
victims' ATM card and destroyed evidence of the crime. Detectives said
she even stole a videotape of her confession that was left unattended
at the police station.
"Holmes destroyed this tape by sneaking
it into the ladies' room and flushing the magnetic tape down the
toilet, after substituting a blank tape in the stack of taped
statements that had been left unsecured on a detective's desk,"
according the the state's brief.
Police also suspect she flushed jewelry she had been wearing, which they suggested may have been stolen from the Brandons.
The Supreme Court previously had banned execution of the mentally retarded, though the
justices established no clear benchmark on IQ test results to guide
criminal courts.
The justices also have closely monitored Louisiana's capital punishment
system in recent years, criticizing in some cases the role of some
prosecutors and the procedural guarantees required in such cases.
The justices last year ordered a new trial for an African-American
capital defendant after finding problems with how prosecutors excluded
blacks from an all-white jury. That same year, the high court blocked
use of the death penalty for a New Orleans-area man convicted of child
rape. Louisiana was one of the few states that had actively pushed
execution for nonhomicide crimes.
Fifty-three women remain on
death row around the country. Forty women have been executed in the
past century -- 11 since 1976 when the Supreme Court restored capital
punishment, according the Death Penalty Information Center.
The
other woman on death row in Louisiana is Antoinette Frank, a former New
Orleans policewoman convicted of three murders, including that of her
former partner on the police force. Her scheduled execution last year
was delayed indefinitely by appeal.
The high court also announced Monday that it will not hear appeals in the following cases:
The
court denied onetime Qwest CEO Joseph Nacchio's appeal of an insider
trading conviction. The court without comment refused to intervene in
Nacchio's request for a new trial or an acquittal. The imprisoned
executive had been convicted of selling $52 million of stock in 2001
without publicly disclosing internal documents showing Denver,
Colorado-based Qwest Communications International was in financial
trouble. He was sentenced to six years in federal prison.
The
justices refused to stop the public release of internal Roman Catholic
Church documents dealing with alleged sexual abuse by priests in the
Bridgeport, Connecticut, Diocese. Nearly two dozen lawsuits had been
filed claiming past abuse, and newspapers had sought thousands of pages
of documents related to the cases. State courts had ruled the material
could be released. The diocese settled the cases in 2001.
Illinois
had refused to approve a "Choose Life" specialty license plate, and a
federal appeals court found officials properly exercised their
discretion when rejecting the message opposing abortion. A private
group claimed its free speech rights were violated. The justices backed
the state by not getting involved. Lower courts also ruled the state
Legislature has the authority to grant a state agency the subjective
power to approve or reject messages on license plates.
A
public employee was fired after announcing he intended to run for
elected office -- in this case the post held by his boss, the Bullitt
County, Kentucky, sheriff. Deputy Sheriff David Greenwell filed suit.
Lower courts sided with the sheriff, and the justices let that ruling
stand. The appeal dealt with whether the sheriff violated the deputy's
First Amendment right to engage in political activity by firing him. The
high court opted not to get involved in a challenge to a Florida state
law requiring parental consent before students in public schools can be
excused from reciting the Pledge of Allegiance in class. A Florida high
school student had been removed from class after remaining seated
during the pledge. The American Civil Liberties Union represented the
student, arguing children could not be forced to stand during the daily
exercise. State officials said the law gives parents the option of
keeping their children out of class when the pledge is recited.